Can't create database 'local'; database exists - when importing

Issue: When I am trying to import a zipped file, it goes through the whole process and at the end it throws the error attached: " Can’t create database ‘local’; database exists".

I am running macOS Catalina. I had a fresh install of the OS and App on this computer and only had the full website files from a backup. I copied them over, so I did not export them and they are not on the flywheel servers to pull down. When I zipped the files, it all looks good until the very end of the process.

Why is it saying the db already exists if this is done on a new computer and install? Any help to resolve would be greatly appreciated!