Thanks Ben.
I did a few things and I’m not sure what fixed it.
- I created a new SSH Key and added the new key to my WP Engine account.
- Then, I disconnected LocalWP and connected again to WP Engine with a new API key.
- Then, I adjusted my ssh folder and file permissions.
- Restarted LocalWP and this seemed to work.
Putting this here in case anyone in the future has the same issue.